Post by Brongaa on Apr 12, 2010 16:44:00 GMT -6
Well, at the moment, we only have 3 rounds for judges to, well, judge. I'll give you status on whether you could judge and how far people are. I'm being extremely loose with this and am currently allowing late compositions. In any of the incomplete groups, if one of you finishes, I will give exactly 24 hours from when they uploaded before I give them a by. Now, on to the stats.
Game A - Incomplete
Status - Phazon has some done, JS hasn't even started, and I'll probably put Phazon through depending on how much he has to show, or he might go to Wild Cards if he doesn't have enough done.
Game B - Incomplete
Status - Youne finished half his song compared to tulane doing none, meaning he clinches an automatic 4th seed.
Game C - Incomplete
Status - Both competitors literally went MIA and I really don't know what's goin' down here. One of the Wild Cards might take their place if I don't see anything soon.
Game D - Complete/Ready to Judge
Score: 4-0 for Eataninja; Clinched spot in Playoff Round
Eataninja : www.youtube.com/watch?v=ogxoGsq9-0o
VS.
drtoadproductions : www.youtube.com/watch?v=YfwktO0Ps1I
Game E - Complete/Ready to Judge + INTENSE
Score: 4-1 for Poptart; Clinched spot for Playoffs
Ultrathing : www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDvKGwqRPBc
VS.
ElectricPoptart : www.youtube.com/watch?v=0etLfuGfVMU
Game F - Complete/Ready to Judge
Score: 4-0 for JF; Clinched spot in Playoff Round
JohnFreeman1337 : www.youtube.com/watch?v=6yU1GYjOrKw
VS.
Brongaa : www.youtube.com/watch?v=-H845nolQPQ
Game A, B, and C, need to be figured out, while the Judges can now judge the last 3 rounds, which will be very interesting to watch, especially Game E. I'm damn happy I ain't a judge for that.
Thanks to Rusty, there will now be a set way to judge.
Here's a PERFECT example of what it should be like:
Ultrathing
---------------
Instrumentation - (9/10) Most of the instrumentation was spot on. The only knock was that the animals, while they worked in most parts, sometimes became too much.
Accuracy - (10/10) Nothing seemed too off.
Volume - (10/10) Everything seemed balanced volume wise.
Overall Feel - (9/10) Overall, while some parts felt a bit choppy, it sounded really deep, and full, which is what I love in an MPC.
Flow - (8.5/10) Some parts didn't seem to flow well, but the majority of the song did.
Wow Factor - (8/10) Some parts did wow me. Especially toward the end of the loop. Love how full everything was, and that risks were taken with some instrument choices.
Creativity - (10/10) Very unique instrument choices, that worked the majority of the time.
Overall Score: 64.5/70 = 92% While it had a few issues in flow, Ultrathing makes up for it in fullness of the sound, and creativity, which is what I love about Ultrathing's style.
Poptart
---------------
Instrumentation - (10/10) Very good instrument choices.
Accuracy - (10/10) Nothing seemed too off.
Volume - (10/10) Everything seemed balanced volume wise.
Overall Feel - (9/10) Some parts seemed a little empty to me, but it was still very well composed.
Flow - (10/10) Everything flowed perfectly.
Wow Factor - (7/10) Everything was flawless. It just doesn't seem to take the amount of risks that Ultrathing's does, and in turn, caught my interest a little less.
Creativity - (9/10) Pretty good way to handle the octave issue, and ways to generate power.
Overall Score: 65/70 = 93% Could have taken a few more risks to make it a bit more interesting, but probably wisely, they weren't taken, and the result was pretty much flawless.
Right now the series are:
Game A - Incomplete
Status - Phazon has some done, JS hasn't even started, and I'll probably put Phazon through depending on how much he has to show, or he might go to Wild Cards if he doesn't have enough done.
Game B - Incomplete
Status - Youne finished half his song compared to tulane doing none, meaning he clinches an automatic 4th seed.
Game C - Incomplete
Status - Both competitors literally went MIA and I really don't know what's goin' down here. One of the Wild Cards might take their place if I don't see anything soon.
Game D - Complete/Ready to Judge
Score: 4-0 for Eataninja; Clinched spot in Playoff Round
Eataninja : www.youtube.com/watch?v=ogxoGsq9-0o
VS.
drtoadproductions : www.youtube.com/watch?v=YfwktO0Ps1I
Game E - Complete/Ready to Judge + INTENSE
Score: 4-1 for Poptart; Clinched spot for Playoffs
Ultrathing : www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDvKGwqRPBc
VS.
ElectricPoptart : www.youtube.com/watch?v=0etLfuGfVMU
Game F - Complete/Ready to Judge
Score: 4-0 for JF; Clinched spot in Playoff Round
JohnFreeman1337 : www.youtube.com/watch?v=6yU1GYjOrKw
VS.
Brongaa : www.youtube.com/watch?v=-H845nolQPQ
Game A, B, and C, need to be figured out, while the Judges can now judge the last 3 rounds, which will be very interesting to watch, especially Game E. I'm damn happy I ain't a judge for that.
Thanks to Rusty, there will now be a set way to judge.
Here's a PERFECT example of what it should be like:
Ultrathing
---------------
Instrumentation - (9/10) Most of the instrumentation was spot on. The only knock was that the animals, while they worked in most parts, sometimes became too much.
Accuracy - (10/10) Nothing seemed too off.
Volume - (10/10) Everything seemed balanced volume wise.
Overall Feel - (9/10) Overall, while some parts felt a bit choppy, it sounded really deep, and full, which is what I love in an MPC.
Flow - (8.5/10) Some parts didn't seem to flow well, but the majority of the song did.
Wow Factor - (8/10) Some parts did wow me. Especially toward the end of the loop. Love how full everything was, and that risks were taken with some instrument choices.
Creativity - (10/10) Very unique instrument choices, that worked the majority of the time.
Overall Score: 64.5/70 = 92% While it had a few issues in flow, Ultrathing makes up for it in fullness of the sound, and creativity, which is what I love about Ultrathing's style.
Poptart
---------------
Instrumentation - (10/10) Very good instrument choices.
Accuracy - (10/10) Nothing seemed too off.
Volume - (10/10) Everything seemed balanced volume wise.
Overall Feel - (9/10) Some parts seemed a little empty to me, but it was still very well composed.
Flow - (10/10) Everything flowed perfectly.
Wow Factor - (7/10) Everything was flawless. It just doesn't seem to take the amount of risks that Ultrathing's does, and in turn, caught my interest a little less.
Creativity - (9/10) Pretty good way to handle the octave issue, and ways to generate power.
Overall Score: 65/70 = 93% Could have taken a few more risks to make it a bit more interesting, but probably wisely, they weren't taken, and the result was pretty much flawless.
Right now the series are: