|
Post by Exarion on Apr 16, 2010 18:28:19 GMT -6
I can't help but to point this out, but your Grammar Nazi-ing days are over KM: Eataninja: Overall Score: 64.5/70 = 93.7% Brongaa: Overall Score: 65.4/70 = 93.4% MATH FAIL KM U LOSSSSE Gah, my bad. Fixed. It may be fixed... but the evidence is still there >:^D
|
|
Jamie
Car
El-Fourth in Command
Wrow
Posts: 508
|
Post by Jamie on Apr 16, 2010 21:23:58 GMT -6
Ultrathing ---------------
Instrumentation - (10/10) Had me fooled, I thought it wasn't even original soundfont. XD This is where the composition excelled. Accuracy - (8/10) A little sloppy here, really. Some parts where the flower seemed to cut off when it shouldn't. The notation is mostly correct, though. Volume - (7/10) Some instruments that should've been quieter or just background sounds were too loud, overpowering what should've been the main melody. Overall Feel - (8/10) There was this thing with the flowers in the first melody where they should be two notes, but he seemed to neglect that harmony. That reduced a lot of the feel for me. It really didn't sound too close to the OST for me. Flow - (7/10) Didn't do so well here, choppy notes and schtuff. Wow Factor - (7/10) Quite a bit, it's good but not great. Creativity - (9/10) Well, this is what ultrathing does. He did some neat experimenting which really won me over, especially with the animals.
Overall Score: 56/70 = 80%
Poptart ---------------
Instrumentation - (7/10) Could've been better. I really didn't like the sound of the mario heads used as higher octave gameboys, comparatively with ultrathing's version. I originally thought it was quite empty sounding, but after listening again, although compared with ultrathing it is a little bit empty, that's not necessarily a bad thing. Accuracy - (9/10) Almost prefect here, just a few minor things I would change. Volume - (10/10) Nothing to complain about at all. Overall Feel - (9/10) No real flaws except for the mario heads. XD Flow - (9/10) Nothing to complain about. Wow Factor - (8/10) Not like, OMG incredible, but it's a damn good, solid work. Creativity - (7/10) Really not as much experimenting going on. Everything is exactly what I'd expect it to be.
Overall Score: 59/70 = 84% Nothing too risky or experimental, but really that doesn't mean it's bad. It's a no-nonsense piece that works well, only complaint is that there's nothing too clever or creative that would make this stand out more.
|
|
|
Post by Youne on Apr 20, 2010 10:18:22 GMT -6
If my post on Rusty's Tournament wasn't read before, I'll repeat it.
I'm sorry for not being able to finish, because of blah blah blah personal stuff, etc.
So, you can either give me the boot, or put me in the wild cards like you said, since I don't deserve to go through with my song 1/2 of the way done.
|
|
|
Post by superiorlarxene on Apr 20, 2010 14:10:49 GMT -6
I can't help but to point this out, but your Grammar Nazi-ing days are over KM: Eataninja: Overall Score: 64.5/70 = 93.7% Brongaa: Overall Score: 65.4/70 = 93.4% MATH FAIL KM U LOSSSSE Lol
|
|
Brongaa
Plane
Official Black Guy of the MPMH
IMMA POP A CAP ON YO' ASS SO DAMN HA- Oh wait, my mom called, brb.
Posts: 836
|
Post by Brongaa on Apr 21, 2010 14:48:26 GMT -6
If my post on Rusty's Tournament wasn't read before, I'll repeat it. I'm sorry for not being able to finish, because of blah blah blah personal stuff, etc. So, you can either give me the boot, or put me in the wild cards like you said, since I don't deserve to go through with my song 1/2 of the way done. Well, if you show it, then we can rate what you have, because tulane won't even finish.
|
|
|
Post by Youne on Apr 22, 2010 0:28:02 GMT -6
Okay then, I'll have it up tomorrow. *expects abysmally low scores*
|
|
|
Post by Youne on Apr 24, 2010 14:31:05 GMT -6
|
|
Brongaa
Plane
Official Black Guy of the MPMH
IMMA POP A CAP ON YO' ASS SO DAMN HA- Oh wait, my mom called, brb.
Posts: 836
|
Post by Brongaa on Apr 24, 2010 15:25:45 GMT -6
Don't worry, I won't force you to get kicked or judged for not finishing.
All I needed that for was seeding, so you'll prolly end up as 4th seed.
|
|