Post by Jamie on Apr 19, 2009 13:58:43 GMT -6
Guys, just to be fair, DON'T GIVE HIM A LOW GRADE BASED OFF HIS ARROGANCE. Like any other composer, rate him based on his SKILL.
That being said, RCPlanes is the second composer to be massly nominated not due to skill (heat being the first). All the composers so far have managed at least a 94%, and they're all big name composers. RCPlanes has skill indeed, but isn't entirely special. He doesn't have those few songs that are just pure win (Like my Don't Stop Me Now, Axel's What is Love, Balloon's anything). Still, he's a decent composer and has good musical sense. I give him a 75%. FEEL THE WRATH OF MY HARSH RATIGNZZZ!!!!
Results so far:
Round 1: Levus28 - 98%
Round 2: BrianLED - 98%
Round 3: SatoshiLyish - 97%
Round 4: theEvilGrimace - 100%
Round 5: Axelrod777 - 98%
Round 6: AngryTigerP - 97%
Round 7: WaluiJ - 97%
Round 8: AdolfoBaez - 99%
Round 9: LoloGuru - 97%
Round 10: Sonicfan113 - 97%
Round 11: Cat333Pokemon - 98%
Round 12: Kacelano - 100%
Round 13: Domino&Reglisse - 100%
Round 14: GuruX@nder - 98%
Round 15: RehdBlob - 95%
Round 16: BlueHeat127 - n/a
Round 17: Banjario - 100%
Round 18: ShinyEspeon - 95%
Round 19: AzureDreams777 - 98%
Round 20: Lihayhm - 97%
Round 21: TomBobBlender - 96%
Round 22: PokeSonicDDRNinja - 94%
Nominations:
Balloon - 83
HCBaily - 61
FriedFischer - 46
phantomtaco - 42
Matmax14 - 41
geoffnet1 - 36
thePieGuy - 32
Eataninja - 23
Cypher8301 - 22
kyoopihd - 20
buckyboy2009 - 15
thepillows92.5 - 14
LordGulcasa - 12
YeOldeBowser - 12
FordPrefect - 10
GRonnoc - 9
MagrogOfMoria - 8
delaythepickup - 7
iHasMario - 7
JohnFreeman - 7
Winterbourne2k - 7
ColotanJP - 6
SuperiorLarxene - 5
yeoldebowser - 5
Snowdog80 - 4
Alexemail1 - 3
KarmaJolt - 2
ButnuggetDoom - 2
Rusty - 2
KLB2007 - 2
NorseFTX - 2
fenix - 2
Dext1005 - 1
hualiang - 1
egg567 - 1
AndyIsAwesome - 1
Doggejern - 1
Nameless2222 - 1
taylorbaldwin - 1
picforlife - 1
ShadowXSnake - 1
Sotomatic - 1
dainegai - 1
51313932 - 1
JillSandwich93 - 1
gallahaut - 1
Standard rules: Give the composer a score out of 100. All the scores given will be averaged together and the composer will be given a final score. Each round lasts 1 week, and new rounds start every Monday morning. Remember to judge them not only on the video(s) posted, but by their composing skills in general. You also get five nomination points as to which composer you want to have done in a future poll. Keep in mind you do not have to use all of your points on one person. And yes, you can nominate yourself.
I homnomnom Larxene.
That being said, RCPlanes is the second composer to be massly nominated not due to skill (heat being the first). All the composers so far have managed at least a 94%, and they're all big name composers. RCPlanes has skill indeed, but isn't entirely special. He doesn't have those few songs that are just pure win (Like my Don't Stop Me Now, Axel's What is Love, Balloon's anything). Still, he's a decent composer and has good musical sense. I give him a 75%. FEEL THE WRATH OF MY HARSH RATIGNZZZ!!!!
Results so far:
Round 1: Levus28 - 98%
Round 2: BrianLED - 98%
Round 3: SatoshiLyish - 97%
Round 4: theEvilGrimace - 100%
Round 5: Axelrod777 - 98%
Round 6: AngryTigerP - 97%
Round 7: WaluiJ - 97%
Round 8: AdolfoBaez - 99%
Round 9: LoloGuru - 97%
Round 10: Sonicfan113 - 97%
Round 11: Cat333Pokemon - 98%
Round 12: Kacelano - 100%
Round 13: Domino&Reglisse - 100%
Round 14: GuruX@nder - 98%
Round 15: RehdBlob - 95%
Round 16: BlueHeat127 - n/a
Round 17: Banjario - 100%
Round 18: ShinyEspeon - 95%
Round 19: AzureDreams777 - 98%
Round 20: Lihayhm - 97%
Round 21: TomBobBlender - 96%
Round 22: PokeSonicDDRNinja - 94%
Nominations:
Balloon - 83
HCBaily - 61
FriedFischer - 46
phantomtaco - 42
Matmax14 - 41
geoffnet1 - 36
thePieGuy - 32
Eataninja - 23
Cypher8301 - 22
kyoopihd - 20
buckyboy2009 - 15
thepillows92.5 - 14
LordGulcasa - 12
YeOldeBowser - 12
FordPrefect - 10
GRonnoc - 9
MagrogOfMoria - 8
delaythepickup - 7
iHasMario - 7
JohnFreeman - 7
Winterbourne2k - 7
ColotanJP - 6
SuperiorLarxene - 5
yeoldebowser - 5
Snowdog80 - 4
Alexemail1 - 3
KarmaJolt - 2
ButnuggetDoom - 2
Rusty - 2
KLB2007 - 2
NorseFTX - 2
fenix - 2
Dext1005 - 1
hualiang - 1
egg567 - 1
AndyIsAwesome - 1
Doggejern - 1
Nameless2222 - 1
taylorbaldwin - 1
picforlife - 1
ShadowXSnake - 1
Sotomatic - 1
dainegai - 1
51313932 - 1
JillSandwich93 - 1
gallahaut - 1
Standard rules: Give the composer a score out of 100. All the scores given will be averaged together and the composer will be given a final score. Each round lasts 1 week, and new rounds start every Monday morning. Remember to judge them not only on the video(s) posted, but by their composing skills in general. You also get five nomination points as to which composer you want to have done in a future poll. Keep in mind you do not have to use all of your points on one person. And yes, you can nominate yourself.
I homnomnom Larxene.